Further to the previous post in which David Shayler was seen to explain how he came to terms with his status as the reincarnation of King Arthur - amongst other things - here is a wonderful video of Mr Rothwell sitting first upon a throne and explaining how he avoided existential crisis by deciding that he was King Arthur and later upon a park bench speaking of his confrontation with doubt and acceptance that magic will provide.
Women want to get with him, apparently. Fight the power.
Sunday, 31 August 2008
Spot The Difference.
John Timothy Rothwell, known to his friends as King Arthur, who in turn are known to him as the Loyal Arthurian Warband, believes he is the reincarnation of the legendary King Arthur of Britain. He’s not alone in elevating himself to the throne, however, as everyone’s favourite discredited spook David Shayler also lays claim to the name and title. I’m sure there must be others. I wouldn’t be surprised if there were enough King Arthurs to fill an entire round table of their own. Perhaps it’s a natural part of the midlife crisis - ditch your wife, grow your hair long, grow a beard, start dating younger women, buy a motorcycle, get religion, grab a sword and announce to the nation that you are King Arthur.
Shayler says that he can change the weather as well, not an unusual claim among people who claim to be pagan or who call themselves witches but I think that those who make it should be aware of the company which they keep. I wouldn’t be surprised if Shayler recants in the next year or so, announces himself as the reincarnation of Obi-Wan Kenobi and starts trading as a reiki master with the ability to heal a myriad of illnesses which medicine cannot touch - only less absurd than being the reincarnation of King Arthur on account of the hordes of unscrupulous con artists who claim to be so miraculously gifted.
Shayler says that he can change the weather as well, not an unusual claim among people who claim to be pagan or who call themselves witches but I think that those who make it should be aware of the company which they keep. I wouldn’t be surprised if Shayler recants in the next year or so, announces himself as the reincarnation of Obi-Wan Kenobi and starts trading as a reiki master with the ability to heal a myriad of illnesses which medicine cannot touch - only less absurd than being the reincarnation of King Arthur on account of the hordes of unscrupulous con artists who claim to be so miraculously gifted.
Thursday, 21 August 2008
Drips in the rain.
Apparently Reiki Retard feels that my arse needs a good kicking. Knowing the car park proclivities of this person I suppose my arse would be lucky if this is all which he tried to give it.
Meanwhile, his sidekick BowelSting (appropriately enough) is shouting off it’s beak about reincarnation, supremely yet mistakenly confident that nobody has spotted that it is posting under the sock puppet identity of giggleFruitbat.
Meanwhile, his sidekick BowelSting (appropriately enough) is shouting off it’s beak about reincarnation, supremely yet mistakenly confident that nobody has spotted that it is posting under the sock puppet identity of giggleFruitbat.
Labels:
BBC,
dogging,
the chuckle brothers,
the pagan topic
Friday, 25 July 2008
Mash It Up.
If modern, Western polytheism seems dominated by laundry lists of Gods whom polytheists claim to have met it is also wrapped around by grocery lists of “sacred texts”.
Recently one polytheist of my acquaintance asked a number of her colleagues - people who mistake vocabulary for scholarliness - to briefly itemise the “sacred texts” which they possessed, with particular emphasis upon those of other religions. The reasons for this poll are irrelevant here but it should be noted that the term “sacred” has not been defined and that subsequent responses included writings which were sacred to the responders and more, the majority of each list, which are sacred to other religions which included some presumed to be sacred to extinct cultures. Several objects which were never intended to be sacred nor which it is fair to consider sacred were also listed.
Let’s have a definition of sacred. We can see that grimoire, tarot cards and DVDs, some of the more bizarre responses given, don’t qualify. The question of definition is important here because there is so much of relativism in modern paganism that we shouldn’t be surprised to notice some pagans walking down the street with their right shoe on their left foot and vice versa declaring, between stumbles and grunts of pain, that the chirality which they assign to their feet is a matter of spiritual preference and that this is a key part of their reconstruction of a great Gnostic-Egyptian-Hellene-Brythonic-Pictish tradition which has been lost to history due to the Christian misinterpretation and misrepresentation of extant sacred texts - including the Bible, the Beano and the instructions which came with their flat-pack chest of drawers - and the rediscovery of previously lost writings beneath the kennel of their fairy great-great-great grandmother’s albino wolf-scotty crossbreed, Lassie.
Now, what relevance do the books of religions dead and gone as well as those here and decidedly not Pagan by current context have to modern, Western pagans? What, say, has Religio Romana to do with the religious beliefs of the Sioux people? Of what relevance is the Egyptian Book of the Dead to hedge-witching? Why would a Heathen retain a Greek New Testament when ditching the rest of her library? Where does Celtic reconstructionism meet with the Bhagavad Gita? Yes, of course a person may retain these in their libraries freely and their reasons for ownership will be diverse, yet why should pagans seems to share an interest in other religions not their own? I would expect, from my own experience, that a straw poll of Christians or Jews or Hindus or Muslims or Buddhists would not produce results even in the neighbourhood of similar to those under discussion here. Why, then, are pagans special in this? Why do they own such a range of books considered sacred by other religions?
It’s simple, really. Modern, literate Western pagans enjoy reading about other religious beliefs because in so doing they feel that they become part of a great tradition of non-Christianity, and to feel justified in abandoning their Christian beliefs and practices, cultural or religious, by reference to great swathes of time in which there were other ways of believing and being. This is not to deny that there are many pagans who accept the epistemological status of their beliefs and who recognise, as I, that a set of beliefs and practices of a handful of years, well-found in thought and consistent, coherent study, and sincerely observed is a tradition as good for the soul - to use a metaphor - and their community as that of any church, synagogue, mosque or temple. Where this is not the case, however, is when study - which sometimes amounts to nothing more than e-books of grimoire and Latin translation downloaded from free sites and the use of heavy, second-hand paperbacks to prevent bookshelves from floating off into space - is not coherently themed, not consistently engaged in and not implemented in the everyday. I assume this is the case because so much of the pagan discourse I encounter, in person and over the internet, seems to consist in no small part of syncretic mash-ups of ideas, names and references from any given religious, philosophical, magical or mystical tradition you may care to mention. I would be surprised if many of these pagans had even read a sacred page of any of the sacred texts they claim to own - whether they own them is another question - yet they see neither nonsense nor disrespect in blithely diluting the sacred beliefs of other peoples in their vain, shallow ignorantly post modern, relativist discourse.
If any of the above describes you then I would ask you to remember that in religion, as in everything else, the value of what you get out is in direct proportion to that which you put in yet you will not, however hard you try, obtain a vital, enduring and useful religion by dumping umpteen “sacred texts” into your simmering cauldron of don’t-want-to-be-Christian soup.
Recently one polytheist of my acquaintance asked a number of her colleagues - people who mistake vocabulary for scholarliness - to briefly itemise the “sacred texts” which they possessed, with particular emphasis upon those of other religions. The reasons for this poll are irrelevant here but it should be noted that the term “sacred” has not been defined and that subsequent responses included writings which were sacred to the responders and more, the majority of each list, which are sacred to other religions which included some presumed to be sacred to extinct cultures. Several objects which were never intended to be sacred nor which it is fair to consider sacred were also listed.
Let’s have a definition of sacred. We can see that grimoire, tarot cards and DVDs, some of the more bizarre responses given, don’t qualify. The question of definition is important here because there is so much of relativism in modern paganism that we shouldn’t be surprised to notice some pagans walking down the street with their right shoe on their left foot and vice versa declaring, between stumbles and grunts of pain, that the chirality which they assign to their feet is a matter of spiritual preference and that this is a key part of their reconstruction of a great Gnostic-Egyptian-Hellene-Brythonic-Pictish tradition which has been lost to history due to the Christian misinterpretation and misrepresentation of extant sacred texts - including the Bible, the Beano and the instructions which came with their flat-pack chest of drawers - and the rediscovery of previously lost writings beneath the kennel of their fairy great-great-great grandmother’s albino wolf-scotty crossbreed, Lassie.
Now, what relevance do the books of religions dead and gone as well as those here and decidedly not Pagan by current context have to modern, Western pagans? What, say, has Religio Romana to do with the religious beliefs of the Sioux people? Of what relevance is the Egyptian Book of the Dead to hedge-witching? Why would a Heathen retain a Greek New Testament when ditching the rest of her library? Where does Celtic reconstructionism meet with the Bhagavad Gita? Yes, of course a person may retain these in their libraries freely and their reasons for ownership will be diverse, yet why should pagans seems to share an interest in other religions not their own? I would expect, from my own experience, that a straw poll of Christians or Jews or Hindus or Muslims or Buddhists would not produce results even in the neighbourhood of similar to those under discussion here. Why, then, are pagans special in this? Why do they own such a range of books considered sacred by other religions?
It’s simple, really. Modern, literate Western pagans enjoy reading about other religious beliefs because in so doing they feel that they become part of a great tradition of non-Christianity, and to feel justified in abandoning their Christian beliefs and practices, cultural or religious, by reference to great swathes of time in which there were other ways of believing and being. This is not to deny that there are many pagans who accept the epistemological status of their beliefs and who recognise, as I, that a set of beliefs and practices of a handful of years, well-found in thought and consistent, coherent study, and sincerely observed is a tradition as good for the soul - to use a metaphor - and their community as that of any church, synagogue, mosque or temple. Where this is not the case, however, is when study - which sometimes amounts to nothing more than e-books of grimoire and Latin translation downloaded from free sites and the use of heavy, second-hand paperbacks to prevent bookshelves from floating off into space - is not coherently themed, not consistently engaged in and not implemented in the everyday. I assume this is the case because so much of the pagan discourse I encounter, in person and over the internet, seems to consist in no small part of syncretic mash-ups of ideas, names and references from any given religious, philosophical, magical or mystical tradition you may care to mention. I would be surprised if many of these pagans had even read a sacred page of any of the sacred texts they claim to own - whether they own them is another question - yet they see neither nonsense nor disrespect in blithely diluting the sacred beliefs of other peoples in their vain, shallow ignorantly post modern, relativist discourse.
If any of the above describes you then I would ask you to remember that in religion, as in everything else, the value of what you get out is in direct proportion to that which you put in yet you will not, however hard you try, obtain a vital, enduring and useful religion by dumping umpteen “sacred texts” into your simmering cauldron of don’t-want-to-be-Christian soup.
Labels:
mash-up,
polytheism,
relativism,
sacred texts,
syncretism
Saturday, 19 July 2008
Godless Pagans.
The Pebble census campaign doesn’t seem to be going quite as it should. According to the above page the aim of the campaign is to achieve the following:
"Paganism will be officially recognized as a serious religious choice;
The government can see that we vote and there are enough of us to make a difference;
Pagan organisations can show they are representative;
We can achieve more representation within the local and wider community;
Pagan organisations will have credibility when dealing with both businesses and the government to provide the services you need."
It’s possible to quibble with this on various points but the main flaw which, judging from their complete lack of any objection to it here, is one about which Pebble doesn’t seem to give a monkey’s soggy arse, is that the Census Diversity Action Group of the Office of National Statistics, which on behalf of the British government will investigate and assess the coherency of paganism as a single religious category albeit subdivided, have adopted the following definition of paganism:
“PAGANISM : The umbrella term for spiritualities and religions that recognise the sacred in nature, the environment, ancestry and heritage.”
Can anyone spot the missing word here? Anyone? You! Yes, you at the back! Speak up there. Again. Yes, that’s it. The definition does not use the word Gods - nor Goddesses for that matter.
Now, how is Pebble to achieve its aims, given above, when paganism will be officially viewed by the Office of National Statistics, the organisers of the census and an organ of the British government, as a group of soppy, gardening, environmentalist genealogist folklorists? Where are the Gods? Don’t any of the members of Pebble actually have Gods in their religions? If yes then do they plan on taking them seriously anytime soon and having Gods mentioned here? Or is it the case that it’s fine to talk about your Gods to other pagans but that when you’re looking for some political and economic clout then Gods may just be brushed under the carpet or shoved into the airing cupboard for fear of pagans looking a little too serious about this whole religion thing? After all, Pebble wants all the pageantry and places of paganism, and pagans and their preferences, or at the very least Pebble itself to be taken seriously by the government. It doesn’t seem, however, as though Pebble wants the government to take their religious beliefs seriously where these involve Gods. Yes, Gods are viewed from a different perspective by pagans than by monotheists yet can you imagine if Christianity were to ditch any mention of God when describing itself? Would they be carpentry-practicing, yeast-averse wine-tasters?
Personally, I would have thought that to omit any mention of Gods from a definition of paganism was a very bad idea, and I would have thought that the Heathen contingent of Pebble, Heathens For Progress, would have ensured that Gods made an appearance in this definition. Perhaps it’s the case, though, that Progress comes before principles, the principle here being that Gods are a big part of many pagan religions, but if the ONS doesn’t like that principle, well then, Pebble and its constituent members have plenty of others. Gods and the pagans who deal with them can go about their business, take up a hobby, form Subbuteo leagues, fly kites or whatever, as long as Pebble gets to sit at the High Table.
Should anyone feel as I do, that Gods should not be omitted from any description of paganism and that Pebble, if they're going to persist in their claim to be representative of pagans and their beliefs, should not permit pagans to be viewed by the government as some kind of secular cosplaying live-RPG club then they may take Pebble’s own advice and stand up and be counted by contacting Pebble to insist that they have significant mention of Gods included in the ONS definition of paganism. Pebble may insist that you sign up you and your friends as one of their partner organisation that they may represent-your-point-of-view-to-the-government-but-no-promises-mind-you, and you may join if you wish. Alternatively, if you wish to circumvent the self-appointed high priests of British paganism then you may contact the Office of National Statistics individually or on behalf of any group of which you are a member and which feels the same way that you may put forward your own point of view.
There is another option, very economic and effective. You might consider it a good idea to keep the government out of your religious beliefs and ignore Pebble altogether. Pebble is not paganism.
"Paganism will be officially recognized as a serious religious choice;
The government can see that we vote and there are enough of us to make a difference;
Pagan organisations can show they are representative;
We can achieve more representation within the local and wider community;
Pagan organisations will have credibility when dealing with both businesses and the government to provide the services you need."
It’s possible to quibble with this on various points but the main flaw which, judging from their complete lack of any objection to it here, is one about which Pebble doesn’t seem to give a monkey’s soggy arse, is that the Census Diversity Action Group of the Office of National Statistics, which on behalf of the British government will investigate and assess the coherency of paganism as a single religious category albeit subdivided, have adopted the following definition of paganism:
“PAGANISM : The umbrella term for spiritualities and religions that recognise the sacred in nature, the environment, ancestry and heritage.”
Can anyone spot the missing word here? Anyone? You! Yes, you at the back! Speak up there. Again. Yes, that’s it. The definition does not use the word Gods - nor Goddesses for that matter.
Now, how is Pebble to achieve its aims, given above, when paganism will be officially viewed by the Office of National Statistics, the organisers of the census and an organ of the British government, as a group of soppy, gardening, environmentalist genealogist folklorists? Where are the Gods? Don’t any of the members of Pebble actually have Gods in their religions? If yes then do they plan on taking them seriously anytime soon and having Gods mentioned here? Or is it the case that it’s fine to talk about your Gods to other pagans but that when you’re looking for some political and economic clout then Gods may just be brushed under the carpet or shoved into the airing cupboard for fear of pagans looking a little too serious about this whole religion thing? After all, Pebble wants all the pageantry and places of paganism, and pagans and their preferences, or at the very least Pebble itself to be taken seriously by the government. It doesn’t seem, however, as though Pebble wants the government to take their religious beliefs seriously where these involve Gods. Yes, Gods are viewed from a different perspective by pagans than by monotheists yet can you imagine if Christianity were to ditch any mention of God when describing itself? Would they be carpentry-practicing, yeast-averse wine-tasters?
Personally, I would have thought that to omit any mention of Gods from a definition of paganism was a very bad idea, and I would have thought that the Heathen contingent of Pebble, Heathens For Progress, would have ensured that Gods made an appearance in this definition. Perhaps it’s the case, though, that Progress comes before principles, the principle here being that Gods are a big part of many pagan religions, but if the ONS doesn’t like that principle, well then, Pebble and its constituent members have plenty of others. Gods and the pagans who deal with them can go about their business, take up a hobby, form Subbuteo leagues, fly kites or whatever, as long as Pebble gets to sit at the High Table.
Should anyone feel as I do, that Gods should not be omitted from any description of paganism and that Pebble, if they're going to persist in their claim to be representative of pagans and their beliefs, should not permit pagans to be viewed by the government as some kind of secular cosplaying live-RPG club then they may take Pebble’s own advice and stand up and be counted by contacting Pebble to insist that they have significant mention of Gods included in the ONS definition of paganism. Pebble may insist that you sign up you and your friends as one of their partner organisation that they may represent-your-point-of-view-to-the-government-but-no-promises-mind-you, and you may join if you wish. Alternatively, if you wish to circumvent the self-appointed high priests of British paganism then you may contact the Office of National Statistics individually or on behalf of any group of which you are a member and which feels the same way that you may put forward your own point of view.
There is another option, very economic and effective. You might consider it a good idea to keep the government out of your religious beliefs and ignore Pebble altogether. Pebble is not paganism.
Labels:
census,
Gods,
Heathens For Progress,
high priests,
pebble
Friday, 18 July 2008
Newspeak.
The funniest thing that I have seen in quite some time is a page from Thorshof called Choosing a Heathen Deity. It rather put me in mind of that childhood game - pre-Playstation - where little geometrically-regular paper toys with numbers and letters written upon them are manipulated until some divination or other is reached. Well, the page itself isn’t the funniest thing, actually. The funniest thing is the realisation that one of the people behind this site, Thorskegga Thorn, is also at the centre of Heathens For Progress and Pebble’s etymological scheme to turbo-charge a Heathen resurgence within Britain by persuading the Oxford English Dictionary that several hundred words and phrases, including Troll-woman, Weodmonath, Leechcraft, Runester, Hlaefmass, Blessing Twig, Helm of Awe and Nine Herbs Charm, be listed within their next edition. Many of the words given are actually already in the dictionary.
I assume this is the intention, anyway, and I look forward to learning of future Pebble projects which will perhaps include a letter-writing campaign to crossword composers insisting that they include words from this list in their puzzles, or perhaps they will picket Channel 4 until Carol Vorderman agrees to start using runic characters during the word rounds of Countdown. That’s the way to do it; indoctrinate the unsuspecting, blue-rinsed British public into pagan ways while they’re dozing over their tea and macaroons.
I assume this is the intention, anyway, and I look forward to learning of future Pebble projects which will perhaps include a letter-writing campaign to crossword composers insisting that they include words from this list in their puzzles, or perhaps they will picket Channel 4 until Carol Vorderman agrees to start using runic characters during the word rounds of Countdown. That’s the way to do it; indoctrinate the unsuspecting, blue-rinsed British public into pagan ways while they’re dozing over their tea and macaroons.
Cunning As Folk.
I’ve just begun to reread a book which I was given as a gift several years ago, the excellent Troublesome Things by the lovely and talented scholar and author Diane Purkiss of Keble College, Oxford.
I cannot recall what prompted me to pick it up once more but I was sufficiently enthused to have a look around the BBC Radio 4 website - the Listen Again facility of which is one of the main reasons for which I maintain an internet connection - and I was delighted to discover an excellent episode of Melvyn Bragg’s In Our Time to which she contributed as a lively and very useful guest on the very subject of fairies which may make exceedingly entertaining Elevenses listening for any interested parties.
One of the other pieces I found on the Radio 4 site was a short interview on Woman‘s Hour, a discussion on male witches and cunning men. It may be thought that a witch is a witch is a witch, but what with everyone and their aunt’s dog describing themselves as a witch these days perhaps it would be better consider the term witch as an honourific bestowed by others. Witch and cunning man both imply wisdom and ability but when each of these consist of nothing more than the same practices, misinformation and alleged spells which anyone can obtain from their nearest bookshop then in what sense is any of this to be considered either wise or able? What is it about a person that allows them to think that they are the peers of those men and women whose names are part of folklore? The ability to swish around in crushed velvet, dye their hair and buy crappy magic wands from websites? It would perhaps be a better state of affairs if people were noted for their obvious common sense, their obvious achievements, their obvious good works for friends, strangers and family in their community, their obvious knowledge of folklore and history than for their brags about alleged abilities to do things which might be considered magical or out of the ordinary that are in the overwhelming majority of cases, frankly, the entirely unwarranted power fantasies of impotent, attention-seeking, feckless people too lazy to get off their backsides, open books, get themselves an education and get involved in the world.
If the title of witch is to be used at all by pagans about one another - and this is by no means a given considering its traditional meaning - then it should not be used trivially, as is the case now.
I cannot recall what prompted me to pick it up once more but I was sufficiently enthused to have a look around the BBC Radio 4 website - the Listen Again facility of which is one of the main reasons for which I maintain an internet connection - and I was delighted to discover an excellent episode of Melvyn Bragg’s In Our Time to which she contributed as a lively and very useful guest on the very subject of fairies which may make exceedingly entertaining Elevenses listening for any interested parties.
One of the other pieces I found on the Radio 4 site was a short interview on Woman‘s Hour, a discussion on male witches and cunning men. It may be thought that a witch is a witch is a witch, but what with everyone and their aunt’s dog describing themselves as a witch these days perhaps it would be better consider the term witch as an honourific bestowed by others. Witch and cunning man both imply wisdom and ability but when each of these consist of nothing more than the same practices, misinformation and alleged spells which anyone can obtain from their nearest bookshop then in what sense is any of this to be considered either wise or able? What is it about a person that allows them to think that they are the peers of those men and women whose names are part of folklore? The ability to swish around in crushed velvet, dye their hair and buy crappy magic wands from websites? It would perhaps be a better state of affairs if people were noted for their obvious common sense, their obvious achievements, their obvious good works for friends, strangers and family in their community, their obvious knowledge of folklore and history than for their brags about alleged abilities to do things which might be considered magical or out of the ordinary that are in the overwhelming majority of cases, frankly, the entirely unwarranted power fantasies of impotent, attention-seeking, feckless people too lazy to get off their backsides, open books, get themselves an education and get involved in the world.
If the title of witch is to be used at all by pagans about one another - and this is by no means a given considering its traditional meaning - then it should not be used trivially, as is the case now.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
